The New York Times reports that states are considering closing prisons to cut spending amid budget deficits.
This illustrates perfectly one of the profound problems with the welfare state: not only does the government focus its money and energies on improper activities such as wealth redistribution, but it defaults on its responsibilities to protect us from criminals.
The effort to cut spending by closing prisons and reducing the number of criminals behind bars means more people will be murdered, raped, and assaulted.
Where is the outrage over that certain outcome? Where are the protesters picketing in front of lawmakers' homes demanding that prisons be kept open?
Wednesday, March 25, 2009
Tuesday, March 24, 2009
Prisons and Stimulus: Perfect Together
The recent murder of four Oakland, CA police officers by a man wanted for violating his parole highlights a problem that is likely to grow with increased Democratic control of government.
The left has been fighting for years to reduce the prison population in the U.S. by various means, including arguing that prisons are overcrowded. One "success" of such efforts has resulted in a panel of federal judges tentatively ordering California to release 50,000 prisoners, over one-third of the total, due to concerns over-crowding has led to a lower quality of medical care.
One of the key factors that has reduced crime in America in the past 15 years has been the greater number of criminals behind bars. If a criminal is in jail, he isn't committing crimes against the broader population. It's simple: release criminals, increase crime.
So here is a solution: build more prisons. The government should do that anyway, good times or bad, to enable it to carry out its fundamental job of protecting us.
But with all of this "stimulus" money sloshing around, such construction activity would be a form of "stimulus" that would be useful, by keeping criminals behind bars.
Funny how that kind of spending didn't get increased, to my knowledge.
Along with the lack of increased military spending (see here), the lack of additional spending on prisons to prevent criminals from being released early illustrates perfectly that the Democrats "stimulus" plan is really about funding its pet social and welfare causes.
The proper role of government is to protect citizens from criminals and foreign threats. The Democrats are defaulting on their responsibility to do just that, while focusing on wealth redistribution and "saving" the environment.
The left has been fighting for years to reduce the prison population in the U.S. by various means, including arguing that prisons are overcrowded. One "success" of such efforts has resulted in a panel of federal judges tentatively ordering California to release 50,000 prisoners, over one-third of the total, due to concerns over-crowding has led to a lower quality of medical care.
One of the key factors that has reduced crime in America in the past 15 years has been the greater number of criminals behind bars. If a criminal is in jail, he isn't committing crimes against the broader population. It's simple: release criminals, increase crime.
So here is a solution: build more prisons. The government should do that anyway, good times or bad, to enable it to carry out its fundamental job of protecting us.
But with all of this "stimulus" money sloshing around, such construction activity would be a form of "stimulus" that would be useful, by keeping criminals behind bars.
Funny how that kind of spending didn't get increased, to my knowledge.
Along with the lack of increased military spending (see here), the lack of additional spending on prisons to prevent criminals from being released early illustrates perfectly that the Democrats "stimulus" plan is really about funding its pet social and welfare causes.
The proper role of government is to protect citizens from criminals and foreign threats. The Democrats are defaulting on their responsibility to do just that, while focusing on wealth redistribution and "saving" the environment.
Monday, March 23, 2009
Outrage
The political and media response to AIG's bonus payments, which appear to be contractually guaranteed, is one of the most outrageous and despicable public acts in recent (and not-so-recent) American history.
Morally, the tax plan is pure wealth confiscation. The 90% excise tax, when combined with state, local, and payroll taxes, is likely to produce a tax rate in excess of 100%. Consider this: during the presidential campaign Barack Obama took umbrage with accusations that his tax policies were a form of socialism, and Joe Biden reacted with disbelief during a TV interview when asked if Obama/Biden's policies were a form of Marxism.
And now the Democratic party wishes to impose taxes that make Obama's tax plans look modest by comparison.
Legally, it is a retroactive tax increase - meaning it is a game of gotcha. There is some debate as to whether it violates the U.S. Constitution's prohibition on Bills of Attainers, which prohibition is designed to prevent the government from imposing specific penalties on specific individuals.
Politically, it represents the rule of the mob. The names of the AIG bonus recipients have been disclosed, which has led to death threats and picketing outside their homes by Acorn "activists".
Is this the activism that Barack Obama cherishes so much?
Worse, the mob may be succeeding in its goals. News reports indicate many of the AIG bonus recipients are returning their bonuses. If you think that is a good thing, consider that now that the mob has won a victory, it will be emboldened for the next issue it seeks to pursue.
Economically, it will reduce the willingness of people to work in the financial sector, particularly TARP firms - making it more likely that the government will lose billions on its TARP investments. The government needs the TARP firms to make lots of money to recoup its investment in them, and the firms need the best talent they can attract and retain to increase profits.
Moreover, the Obama administration introduced today its latest plan to combat the problems confronting the financial sector, after its initial plan a month ago lacked specifics and was poorly received. The new plan entails the government partnering with large investors to purchase assets from banks, with the government providing attractive terms to investors to induce them to participate.
The government will now have to make those terms even more attractive to encourage investors to participate, since the risk of doing business with the government is so high - with the investors having to ask: will they be allowed to keep the profits that they hope to earn from such investments, given the frenzy over the bonuses paid to TARPed firms?
The government will lose far far more money, from further losses on its TARP investments and increased subsidies to investors in the latest bailout plan, then the amount of the AIG bonuses.
And Barack Obama has been AWOL in terms of exerting presidential leadership on the issue. For a man who made his political career by not taking hard stands (witness his huge number of missed votes when he was an Illinois state legislature - if you don't vote, then a constituency who doesn't like your vote can't be upset with you), he now confronts making tough choices.
Yes, he has made tentative comments expressing his concern with the tax plan. But real leadership means speaking out, even if it isn't popular.
The silence is deafening, and disturbing.
Saturday, March 14, 2009
Gone Fishin'
Well, not quite fishing, but I am going on vacation and should be resuming my posts on March 23.
Friday, March 13, 2009
Stimulus Spending that Makes Sense
The Democrats' "stimulus" bill that recently passed was noticeably short on added spending in one area where the extra spending could be effective and not increase deficits over the next five years: military spending, particularly arms procurement.
The military plans to purchase weapons systems over time, so a sensible stimulus plan would have been to accelerate weapons purchases that would occur anyway. This would expand defense contractor' employment today, at the cost of such employment several years from now when presumably the economy is recovering.
Moreover, the spending would be on goods that we were planning to buy anyway, as compared to squandering our tax dollars on politically attractive projects or spending for spending's sake.
There is no stronger evidence of the "stimulus" bill being a vehicle to spend money on Democrats' pet projects, causes, and constituencies than this.
The military plans to purchase weapons systems over time, so a sensible stimulus plan would have been to accelerate weapons purchases that would occur anyway. This would expand defense contractor' employment today, at the cost of such employment several years from now when presumably the economy is recovering.
Moreover, the spending would be on goods that we were planning to buy anyway, as compared to squandering our tax dollars on politically attractive projects or spending for spending's sake.
There is no stronger evidence of the "stimulus" bill being a vehicle to spend money on Democrats' pet projects, causes, and constituencies than this.
Do as the Europeans Do?
In America, the left often uses policies that predominate in Europe as an argument for their introduction or expansion in the U.S.: national health care, labor regulations, and the death penalty top the list.
But when it comes to "stimulus" spending, Europe has taken a much tougher line than the Democrats' spend-till-we-drop approach. The leading European nations have announced "stimulus" plans that are a much smaller percentage of GDP that America's.
Don't hold your breath for our left to suggest we mimic Europe in this regard. In fact, the Obama administration is pushing Europe to spend more, but those nations are resisting such entreaties out of a concern that spending sprees won't do much good but will increase their debt burdens.
But when it comes to "stimulus" spending, Europe has taken a much tougher line than the Democrats' spend-till-we-drop approach. The leading European nations have announced "stimulus" plans that are a much smaller percentage of GDP that America's.
Don't hold your breath for our left to suggest we mimic Europe in this regard. In fact, the Obama administration is pushing Europe to spend more, but those nations are resisting such entreaties out of a concern that spending sprees won't do much good but will increase their debt burdens.
Pork Has its Privileges
The Senate voted 62-35 to pass the pork laden, $410 billion spending bill.
Unfortunately, eight Republicans voted in favor of the bill (see who the eight are here); without their support, the bill wouldn't have received the 60 votes necessary to pass. In addition to billions for earmarks, this latest money grab represents an 8.7% increase in discretionary spending over last year - at a time of no inflation.
The spending spree continues, and while most Republicans are doing good work in opposing it, this bill and the "stimulus" plan wouldn't have passed with some Republican support.
Being a Democrat-lite won't help the Republican party regain political support.
The spending spree continues, and while most Republicans are doing good work in opposing it, this bill and the "stimulus" plan wouldn't have passed with some Republican support.
Being a Democrat-lite won't help the Republican party regain political support.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)